As the holiday gifting season approaches, shoppers across the country are faced with a decision: Black Friday or Cyber Monday? The age-old debate between strolling the mall or surfing the web has taken on new significance in recent years, with e-commerce emerging as a preferred shopping method for many. According to a report from the U.S. Census Bureau, U.S. retail e-commerce sales in the third quarter of 2024 totaled over $300 billion, marking a 7.4% increase from the previous year. This trend towards online shopping is having a noticeable impact on brick-and-mortar businesses in cities like Providence.
Rachel Chevrette, co-owner of Four Buds Floral Studio on Wickenden Street, shared her experience of Small Business Saturday being a disappointment, with minimal foot traffic in her store. She noted that some Providence shoppers are turning to online shopping due to both financial considerations and convenience. Eloise Mahoney, a local shopper, mentioned that she sometimes opts for Amazon because it’s easier, but she tries to support small businesses whenever possible.
Carla Doughty, Zero Waste Providence Projects Coordinator, emphasized the importance of prioritizing local, small-scale, and handmade goods when shopping. She cautioned against relying on online retailers that offer cheap, mass-produced items, highlighting the environmental impact of fast fashion and shipping. Doughty suggested exploring local shops in Providence, such as those on Westminster, Broadway, and Brook streets, as well as thrift stores and item swaps, as sustainable alternatives to online shopping.
While online shopping offers convenience and a wide selection of products, shopping in person provides a unique experience and the opportunity for impeccable customer service. Wendy Canniff, who works at Gallery Belleau, a glass art gallery on Wickenden Street, expressed disappointment in the decline of in-person sales due to the rise of online shopping. She emphasized the tactile experience of shopping and the value of supporting local businesses.
Doughty also highlighted the importance of mindful consumption and finding alternative ways to give during the holiday season. She shared a personal anecdote of giving her nephew a rock as a gift, which he cherished just as much as a high-tech gadget. Doughty encouraged shoppers to consider investing in meaningful gifts, supporting causes they believe in, or creating thoughtful presents rather than accumulating more stuff.
In conclusion, the choice between Black Friday and Cyber Monday, online shopping and in-person shopping, is a personal one that reflects individual values and priorities. While online shopping offers convenience and accessibility, shopping in person supports local businesses, fosters community connections, and reduces environmental impact. Ultimately, the holiday season presents an opportunity to rethink our consumption habits and consider the true cost of our purchases. By supporting local businesses, shopping mindfully, and finding creative ways to give, we can make a positive impact on our communities and the planet.
